Mettez-vous hors ligne avec l'application Player FM !
#34: What is Illness? — Dr. Amanda Rabinowitz
Manage episode 284465419 series 1912304
Researcher and clinical psychology PhD Amanda Rabinowitz returns to Redeeming Disorder to talk psychiatry, dive deeper into therapeutic techniques (especially CBT and its behavioral activation offshoots) and contemplate a number of murky dichotomies within her field:
- Nature vs. Nurture
- Categorical vs. Dimensional Thinking
- Suppression of vs. Identification with Mental "Illnesses"
- Collectivist vs. Individualist Perspectives
- Cultural Context vs. Universality
As a whole, Amanda's interview underscores dichotomies within the whole of psychology — dichotomies in which her approach contrasts with that of our last guest, Dr. Eric Maisel. Where Eric calls disorders made-up, psychiatry corrupt and its systems illegitimate, Amanda calls disorders sociologically valuable, psychiatry complicated and its systems worth working within. I don't pretend to know who is right, or if either of these psychologists is right. I don't particularly think that's important. In Eric Maisel and Amanda Rabinowitz I see two people carrying out a labor of love, with tremendous intelligence and compassion, impactfully helping others.
Support Redeeming Disorder by contributing to their Tip Jar: https://tips.pinecast.com/jar/redeeming-disorder
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit reiman.substack.com
63 episodes
Manage episode 284465419 series 1912304
Researcher and clinical psychology PhD Amanda Rabinowitz returns to Redeeming Disorder to talk psychiatry, dive deeper into therapeutic techniques (especially CBT and its behavioral activation offshoots) and contemplate a number of murky dichotomies within her field:
- Nature vs. Nurture
- Categorical vs. Dimensional Thinking
- Suppression of vs. Identification with Mental "Illnesses"
- Collectivist vs. Individualist Perspectives
- Cultural Context vs. Universality
As a whole, Amanda's interview underscores dichotomies within the whole of psychology — dichotomies in which her approach contrasts with that of our last guest, Dr. Eric Maisel. Where Eric calls disorders made-up, psychiatry corrupt and its systems illegitimate, Amanda calls disorders sociologically valuable, psychiatry complicated and its systems worth working within. I don't pretend to know who is right, or if either of these psychologists is right. I don't particularly think that's important. In Eric Maisel and Amanda Rabinowitz I see two people carrying out a labor of love, with tremendous intelligence and compassion, impactfully helping others.
Support Redeeming Disorder by contributing to their Tip Jar: https://tips.pinecast.com/jar/redeeming-disorder
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit reiman.substack.com
63 episodes
كل الحلقات
×Bienvenue sur Lecteur FM!
Lecteur FM recherche sur Internet des podcasts de haute qualité que vous pourrez apprécier dès maintenant. C'est la meilleure application de podcast et fonctionne sur Android, iPhone et le Web. Inscrivez-vous pour synchroniser les abonnements sur tous les appareils.